Kentucky’s no-fault law limits lawsuits for pain and suffering after a motor vehicle crash unless the injury meets a statutory threshold. A catastrophic injury can meet more than one threshold, and the statute is where each one is defined.
Benefits Replace Tort Liability at First
KRS 304.39-060 abolishes tort liability for bodily injury from a motor vehicle accident to the extent basic reparation benefits are payable, subject to an exception for noneconomic detriment that qualifies under paragraph (b). A plaintiff may sue for pain, suffering, mental anguish, and inconvenience only when a threshold is met.
Tort liability stays abolished for the losses those benefits cover, so the threshold matters for noneconomic damages such as pain and suffering. It doesn’t decide whether benefits are payable in the first place.
The Statute Lists Eight Ways to Meet the Threshold
Paragraph (b) allows a claim for pain and suffering when any one of these is met:
- Medical expense benefits that exceed $1,000 when excluded or deductible amounts are counted.
- Permanent disfigurement caused by the accident.
- A fracture to a bone as part of the injury.
- A compound, comminuted, displaced, or compressed fracture.
- Loss of a body member in the accident.
- Permanent injury within reasonable medical probability.
- Permanent loss of a bodily function after the accident.
- Death of the injured person from the accident.
Someone weighing a claim for a catastrophic injury can ask an Owensboro catastrophic injury lawyer which threshold the medical records support. Because only one threshold is required, the records need to support at least one of them.
Medical Terms the Statute Names Need Matching Records
The statute names a fracture to a bone and, as a separate item, four fracture types: compound, comminuted, displaced, and compressed. Imaging reports and surgical notes should name the fracture in those terms.
Medical bills that exceed $1,000 meet one threshold, but the lasting expenses of a catastrophic injury can extend past that figure, so long-term injury costs belong in the file from the first treatment. A running list of treatment dates and bills shows how the total builds.
Permanence Needs a Medical Opinion
The permanent injury and permanent loss of function categories turn on a medical opinion, because the statute asks about permanence within reasonable medical probability. Probability is the standard. A treating physician’s records should state permanence in those terms.
Those records matter in catastrophic injury claims where future care is at stake. Dates, diagnoses, and treatment plans give the opinion something concrete to rest on.
Some Claimants Face No Threshold at All
Paragraph (c) says tort liability isn’t limited for injury to a person who isn’t an owner, operator, maintainer, or user of a motor vehicle. It also isn’t limited for injury to the passenger of a motorcycle arising out of the motorcycle’s maintenance or use.
The Same Paragraph Covers Deaths and Fractures
Death is one of the listed thresholds, which places a fatal crash within paragraph (b). Injuries short of catastrophic, such as a fracture, go through the same paragraph.
Families dealing with a death also have wrongful death claims to consider, and the threshold list names death directly. The medical expense benefits already paid should still be recorded, because the threshold for medical expense counts them.
Someone with a fracture or a large medical bill can ask an Owensboro personal injury lawyer whether the threshold has been met. Medical expense alone can satisfy the statute when no other category applies.
Benefits Records Belong in the Claim File
A claim file should record the medical expense benefits paid so far, because the $1,000 figure counts benefits that would be payable but for an exclusion or deductible. Each payment and adjustment should be listed with its date.
The threshold works alongside the rest of Kentucky no-fault insurance, so benefit payments belong in the same file as the treatment records. A running total shows how close the claim is to the $1,000 figure.
Matching the Injury to the Statute
A threshold that is met on paper still has to be shown with records. Fractures, surgeries, and permanent limits should be documented early.
Our founding attorney Brian S. Katz was admitted in Tennessee in 1991 and in Kentucky in 1997, and he founded Katz Law in Paducah. His recognitions include Super Lawyers and the Million Dollar Advocates Forum.
Putting the Statute to Work for the Claim
The eight categories give a claim its outline. Each one points to a type of record that should exist before a demand is made.
Anyone in Owensboro hurt in a serious crash can reach out to an Owensboro catastrophic injury lawyer to match each injury to the category the statute names before the claim moves forward. Imaging, surgical, and billing records each speak to a different category.